Fence marketing guide

Local Services Ads vs Google Ads for fence companies

Are Local Services Ads worth it for a fence company, and how do they compare with Google Search ads? Short answer: run both, and judge them on cost per sold job.

You talk to Marcus, the owner. Bring your numbers.

For most fence companies, the answer is both. Local Services Ads usually bring cheaper leads but cap out on volume. Google Search ads cost more per lead but give you control and room to grow. Judge them side by side on what a sold fence costs, not on what a lead costs.

Below is how each one works, what changes now that Google is moving Local Services Ads into Google Ads, and how to decide where the next dollar goes.

What is the difference between Local Services Ads and Google Ads?

Local Services Ads (LSA) are the boxes at the very top of a search like “fence company near me”, often with a Google badge. You pay when a homeowner calls or messages you, not when they click. Google decides who shows based mostly on your reviews, how responsive you are, your distance from the searcher and your bid.

Google Search ads are the text ads below LSA and above the regular results. You pay per click. You choose the searches you show for, write the ad, and pick the page the click lands on.

The short version:

  • LSA: pay per lead, little control, ranking driven by reviews and responsiveness

  • Search ads: pay per click, full control of keywords, ads and landing pages

  • LSA leads tend to cost less each, but volume tops out

  • Search leads tend to cost more each, but you can keep adding searches, towns and services

Are Google Local Services Ads worth it for a fence company?

Usually, yes, if you have reviews and someone answers the phone. LSA is often the cheapest paid lead a fence company can buy, because you only pay when a homeowner reaches out.

It stops being worth it in three cases:

  • You have few reviews. LSA ranking leans hard on review count and rating. A profile with a handful of reviews rarely shows often enough to matter.

  • You miss calls. Responsiveness affects how often you show. Missed calls cost you twice: the lead and your future placement.

  • You are already showing for most searches. Past that point, more budget buys very little. That is the signal to add Search ads, not to raise the LSA budget.

How do Google LSA reviews work?

Reviews on your Google Business Profile feed your Local Services Ads. Two things matter: how many you have in total and how recently they keep coming in.

Total count has the most immediate effect, so send most review requests to your main profile. A new profile should get its first 10 reviews quickly. After that, aim for a steady pace rather than bursts, and ask every happy customer the same week the fence goes in, while the job is fresh.

You can dispute a review that breaks Google’s rules. You cannot remove an honest bad one. Reply to it calmly and fix what you can. Homeowners read the replies.

What changes now that LSA is moving into Google Ads?

Google is moving Local Services Ads into Google Ads accounts in phases, trade by trade, with an email notice before each account moves. Check your inbox and your LSA dashboard for the date on yours.

What stays the same:

  • You still pay per lead, not per click

  • Your ads still show in the same places at the top of the search

  • Your Business Profile details and reviews still feed the ads

What changes:

  • LSA is managed inside Google Ads, next to your Search campaigns

  • Manual bidding and separate bids for each job type go away; accounts on them get one target for the whole campaign, set to the highest bid you had

  • The weekly budget becomes a daily budget

  • Your old LSA reports do not come with you

Do this before your account moves: download at least 12 months of LSA lead reports. If you set different bids for different job types, decide whether to split them into separate campaigns or accept one target. If you skip this, your history is gone and your bids may jump on day one.

LSA vs Google Ads: how to compare them fairly

Most owners compare the two on cost per lead, and LSA almost always wins that contest. It is the wrong contest.

Cheaper leads do not always close as often. A homeowner who taps the top LSA box may call three companies. A homeowner who searched “vinyl privacy fence installer”, read your page and filled out your form often picked you. The gap in cost per lead can shrink a lot, or disappear, once you count sold jobs.

To compare them fairly you need three things:

  • A source on every lead. LSA leads are labeled in the platform. Search leads need call tracking on your website and every form tagged.

  • Sales in your CRM. Every sold fence recorded with its value and the date.

  • A match between the two. Each sold job tied back to the lead that started it.

Then the math is simple: cost per sold job is ad spend divided by sold jobs, for each channel. Whichever is lower gets the next dollar, until it stops being lower. Our call tracking and attribution page shows how we set this up.

Should a fence company run both?

In most markets, yes. Start with LSA if your reviews are solid, because it is the quickest way to cheap, exclusive leads. Add Search ads when one of these is true:

  • LSA has stopped growing even with a higher budget

  • You want jobs LSA does not cover well, like commercial fencing or specific materials

  • You want to reach towns where your map ranking is weak

Do not turn Search off because its leads cost more, and do not cut LSA because you added Search. Fund both, watch cost per sold job, and move budget toward whichever is cheaper per fence.

Common mistakes we see

  • Judging on cost per lead. It hides close rates, which is where the real difference is.

  • Letting reviews stall. LSA placement drops quietly when reviews stop coming in.

  • Sending Search clicks to the homepage. A dedicated page with one offer and a short estimate form converts more of the clicks you pay for.

  • No tracking on website calls. Many accounts count calls from the ad itself and miss calls from the website, so good Search campaigns look bad.

  • Ignoring the migration email. Old reports are lost if you do not export them first.

The bottom line

Local Services Ads are worth it for most fence companies with reviews and fast callbacks. Google Search ads are how you grow past LSA’s ceiling. Run both, track every lead to a sale, and let cost per sold job decide the budget.

For the full setup, see Google Ads for fence companies and marketing for fence companies.

Free download

The Fence Marketing Playbook

A free PDF for fence company owners: how to market a fence company step by step, and how to judge every channel on cost per sold job.

Start with a free assessment

Send us your website. We check your tracking, your Google Ads tag, call tracking, forms, booking, local SEO basics and mobile speed. You get a page showing what is working and what is broken. Free, and useful on its own.

© 2025 MILE ZERO MARKETING

Made with 💙 by Third Space Design